The size of the card changes almost everything about MyGiftCardSupply's Xbox Credits prices. Its $15 card costs $17.97, which is 19.8% above face value. Its $100 card costs $104.97, only 5.0% above face value. Across its four card values, the cost per dollar of Xbox credit falls by 12.4%, the steepest decline of any card list we looked at from this seller.
That falling markup also pulls MyGiftCardSupply closer to the cheapest quote on the site as the card gets bigger. It is 15.3% above the cheapest on the $25 card, 13.5% above on the $50 card and 11.7% above on the $100 card. On the $15 card it is the only seller quoting at all.
MyGiftCardSupply carries a third-party seller label. Prices are in US dollars, and a "25" pack is a $25 Xbox gift card. The quotes are the same in every country we checked, so there is no country-specific price here.
MyGiftCardSupply's Xbox list against the market
| Pack | MyGiftCardSupply price | Rank | Cheapest on the site | Seller of cheapest | Gap | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | $15 card | $17.97 | 1 of 1 | $17.97 | MyGiftCardSupply | — | | $25 card | $27.97 | 3 of 3 | $24.25 | Skine | $3.72 (15.3%) | | $50 card | $53.92 | 2 of 2 | $47.50 | Skine | $6.42 (13.5%) | | $100 card | $104.97 | 2 of 2 | $94.00 | Skine | $10.97 (11.7%) |
Gap is MyGiftCardSupply's price minus the cheapest, with the percentage measured against the cheapest quote. Check the final price at checkout, since some sellers add fees there.
The field on Xbox Credits is narrow. The $25 card has three sellers, the $50 and $100 cards have two each, and the $15 card has one. Every rank above is a comparison against at most two other prices.
How the markup shrinks
The cleanest way to see the curve is the cost of each $100 of Xbox credit, which is the price divided by the face value, times 100.
| Pack | MyGiftCardSupply per $100 | Over face value | Cheapest per $100 | Gap | |---|---|---|---|---| | $15 card | $119.80 | 19.8% | — | — | | $25 card | $111.88 | 11.9% | $97.00 | 15.3% | | $50 card | $107.84 | 7.8% | $95.00 | 13.5% | | $100 card | $104.97 | 5.0% | $94.00 | 11.7% |
Every step up in card size lowers MyGiftCardSupply's cost per dollar, and none goes backwards. The biggest single drop is from the $15 card to the $25 card, 6.6%, from $119.80 to $111.88 per $100. The steps after that are smaller but steady.
There is a simple pattern underneath. In dollars, MyGiftCardSupply's markup over face value barely changes: it is $2.97 on the $15 card, $2.97 on the $25 card, $3.92 on the $50 card and $4.97 on the $100 card. A roughly fixed few dollars spread over a bigger card makes a much smaller percentage. That is why the $100 card is so much better value per dollar than the $15 card.
The cheapest quote on the site falls too, from $97.00 to $94.00 per $100 across the three shared cards, but more slowly than MyGiftCardSupply's. So the gap narrows with size, from 15.3% to 11.7%.
The other Xbox Credits sellers
Three sellers list Xbox credit on MangoRecharge: Kinguin, MyGiftCardSupply and Skine.
- Skine quotes the $25, $50 and $100 cards and has the lowest price on all three, at $24.25, $47.50 and $94.00.
- Kinguin, an established reseller, quotes only the $25 card, at $24.48. That puts it $0.23 above Skine and $3.49, or 14.3%, below MyGiftCardSupply.
- MyGiftCardSupply quotes all four cards, including the $15 card no one else lists.
So on the $25 card, the only Xbox value with three sellers, MyGiftCardSupply is last, and the established reseller on that card is cheaper by $3.49. On the $50 and $100 cards, it is one of only two quotes.
How to use this
If you are buying from MyGiftCardSupply, the $100 card is clearly its best value. It has the lowest markup over face value, 5.0%, and the smallest gap to the cheapest quote, 11.7%. The $15 card is the opposite: the highest markup, at 19.8%, though it is also the only $15 Xbox card quoted on the site.
Splitting a purchase into smaller cards costs noticeably more here. Two $50 cards from MyGiftCardSupply come to $107.84, which is $2.87 more than its single $100 card. Four $25 cards come to $111.88, which is $6.91 more. On this list, buy the largest card that fits what you need.
A short checklist before buying:
- Make sure the card matches your Microsoft account region.
- Look at the final checkout total, not just the listed price.
- If you need less than $25 of credit, note that the $15 card is the only small option shown.
You can compare all Xbox Credits sellers on one page, with each card value in its own row.
Prices change
With so few sellers per card, one price change can reorder the Xbox list. The figures in this post reflect the quotes at the time of writing, and the compare page shows the current sellers and prices for every card value.
