MyGiftCardSupply quotes five Apple iTunes card values on MangoRecharge, and the picture splits cleanly in two. On the $200 card it is the only seller quoting at all, at $229.92. On the four smaller cards, $15 through $100, it is one of two sellers and has the higher price every time, by $2.07 on the $15 card and by $15.92 on the $100 card.
MyGiftCardSupply carries a third-party seller label on the site. The card values below are US dollar denominations, so a "25" pack is a $25 Apple card, and every price is in US dollars. The same quotes appear in every country we checked, so there is no country-specific price here.
MyGiftCardSupply against the cheapest quote
| Pack | MyGiftCardSupply price | Rank | Cheapest on the site | Seller of cheapest | Gap | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | $15 card | $17.97 | 2 of 2 | $15.90 | Skine | $2.07 (13.0%) | | $25 card | $29.92 | 2 of 2 | $26.00 | Skine | $3.92 (15.1%) | | $50 card | $58.92 | 2 of 2 | $51.00 | Skine | $7.92 (15.5%) | | $100 card | $116.92 | 2 of 2 | $101.00 | Skine | $15.92 (15.8%) | | $200 card | $229.92 | 1 of 1 | $229.92 | MyGiftCardSupply | — |
Gap is MyGiftCardSupply's price minus the cheapest quote, with the percentage measured against the cheapest quote. Skine is also a third-party seller; check the final price at checkout, since some sellers add fees there.
Two things stand out. First, the field is very thin. No pack has more than two sellers, which means each rank and each gap is a comparison against one rival, not against a broad market. Second, the gap in dollars grows quickly with card size, from $2.07 to $15.92, while the gap in percentage moves much less, from 13.0% to 15.8%. Most of the dollar growth is simply the card getting bigger.
What each dollar of credit costs
A gift card is easiest to judge by what you pay for each $100 of card value. That is the price divided by the face value, multiplied by 100.
| Pack | MyGiftCardSupply per $100 | Cheapest per $100 | MyGiftCardSupply above cheapest | |---|---|---|---| | $15 card | $119.80 | $106.00 | 13.0% | | $25 card | $119.68 | $104.00 | 15.1% | | $50 card | $117.84 | $102.00 | 15.5% | | $100 card | $116.92 | $101.00 | 15.8% | | $200 card | $114.96 | — | — |
MyGiftCardSupply's cost per $100 of credit falls with every step up in card size. It goes from $119.80 on the $15 card to $114.96 on the $200 card, a drop of 4.0%. Put another way, the $15 card costs $2.97 more than its face value, a 19.8% premium, while the $200 card costs $29.92 more than face, a 15.0% premium. Larger cards are relatively cheaper here, and the curve never turns back up.
The trouble is that the cheapest quote falls faster. On the four packs both sellers share, the lowest price per $100 goes from $106.00 to $101.00, a drop of 4.7%, while MyGiftCardSupply's goes from $119.80 to $116.92, a drop of 2.4%. So MyGiftCardSupply's percentage gap widens as the card gets bigger, from 13.0% on the $15 card to 15.8% on the $100 card. Its best relative standing is on the smallest card, even though its best absolute value per dollar is on the largest.
The other sellers on Apple iTunes
Four sellers list Apple iTunes credit on MangoRecharge: Dundle, Kinguin, MyGiftCardSupply and Skine. Only two of them, MyGiftCardSupply and Skine, quote the five card values covered in this post. Dundle and Kinguin do not appear on any of these five packs.
Between the two that do, the split is simple:
- Skine has the lower quote on the $15, $25, $50 and $100 cards. It does not quote the $200 card.
- MyGiftCardSupply has the higher quote on those four, and is alone on the $200 card.
There is no pack where a third seller sits in between, so there is no middle ground to compare. If you want a $200 card from this list in one purchase, MyGiftCardSupply is the only option shown. If a smaller card or a combination of smaller cards suits you, the lower quote on each of those sits with the other seller.
One practical comparison: two $100 cards at the cheapest quote come to $202.00, against $229.92 for MyGiftCardSupply's single $200 card. Two of MyGiftCardSupply's own $100 cards come to $233.84, which is $3.92 more than its $200 card. So within MyGiftCardSupply's own list, the single larger card is the better buy, but across the site the two smaller cards cost less in total.
How to use this
If you are already set on buying from MyGiftCardSupply, the $200 card gives the lowest cost per dollar of credit on its list, at $114.96 per $100. Each step down in card size costs a little more per dollar, and the $15 and $25 cards are the most expensive per dollar at close to $120 per $100.
If you are comparing across sellers, the pattern is the reverse. MyGiftCardSupply's gap to the cheapest quote is narrowest on the $15 card, at 13.0%, and widest on the $100 card, at 15.8%. On every card value where it has company, it is the higher of the two prices.
Before you buy, it is worth checking a few points:
- Confirm the card is for the Apple account region you use. The prices above are for US dollar cards.
- Compare the total for one large card against several smaller ones, as in the $200 example above.
- Look at the final checkout total, not just the listed price.
You can compare all Apple iTunes sellers side by side, with each card value in its own row.
A note on these prices
Gift card prices move, and the ranking on a given card can change when one seller adjusts its list. The figures in this post reflect the quotes at the time of writing. The compare page always shows the current list of sellers and prices for each Apple iTunes card value, so check it before you buy.
